Key themes covered by international experts highlighted how the safety in use, cost-competitiveness, proven durability and recyclability of PVC pipes for water, gas and sewer sectors across the lifetime of the infrastructures have made them a sustainable choice for delivering essential services reliably for more than eight decades.
The event, co-organized with PVC Forum Italia, attracted more than 95 participants from 13 countries, including representatives from the whole supply chain: utilities, pipe manufacturers, compounders, equipment manufacturers, raw material suppliers and certification bodies.
“PVC was the first plastic used to produce pipes industrially in Germany in the 1930s and some of these pipes are still in service today,” said Vincent Stone, PVC4Pipes Project Leader. “Ensuring a proper quality to PVC pipes has been a priority for the PVC pipe industry from the very beginning, with the 3 first quality and testing standards issued in 1941. Comparison studies have shown that the short- and long-term performances of these first pipes nearly matched those of modern PVC-U pipes.”
In a comprehensive update on the PVC pipes market and trends, Astrid Aupetit from AMI Consulting said the European PVC pipes market accounted for 5.2 million tonnes in 2018 and is growing at over 4.5% annually to 2023. Growth drivers are greater awareness of the benefits of plastic pipes versus other materials and material substitution, with technical innovations widening the potential market. PVC maintains a large market share in most countries, mainly for gravity pipes with more than 55% market share.
PVC pipes – the smart choice for utilities and the circular economy
In a review of the Circular Economy Network Project exploring the use of recycled plastics in network services, Emilio Caporossi from Gruppo Hera announced the launch of the installation of about 800 m of multi-layer/structured wall PVC sewer pipes including recycled material in Vedrana. Caporossi also mentioned that break rates in Hera’s water networks amounted to 0.07 break/km/year for the PVC pipes vs. 0.52 for the PE pipes.
PVC pipes as the smart choice for utilities was illustrated by Alessandro Marangoni of Althesys. He confirmed that PVC-U is the best total cost of ownership performer compared to other non-plastic materials for water and sewer pipes across the lifetime of the infrastructures, which has been shown to exceed 100 years. PVC pipes are around 28% less costly than ductile iron, with the main savings realised on installation costs, and offer significant economic advantages for network owners.
Bruce Hollands, from the Uni-Bell PVC Pipe Association, shared findings from studies evaluating the cost and sustainability of underground piping that can help municipalities to drive their investment decisions. These showed that where alternative PVC pipe materials were chosen, cost savings were achieved, and PVC pipe had the lowest break rate. He concluded: “A sensible local procurement approach can take advantage of changes in pipe materials not only on a cost basis, but also performance characteristics. The case for considering alternative pipe materials that might perform as good or better than conventional pipes used today, and cost less, is compelling.”
A session examining regulatory drivers to sustainability included an overview of migration modelling methods to reduce compliance costs for contact with drinking water from Christoph Losher and Peter Mercea, FABES. Mercea said: “Migration modelling can be used to test or screen for compliance quickly and at low costs for various manufacturing scenarios and solutions. For PVC pipes typically showing migration levels far below the detection limits of the most sensitive analytical methods, it is very often the only method that can be used to estimate a migration concentration.”
Frontrunners in circularity
Demonstrating that PVC pipes are ‘frontrunners in circularity’, Roger Loop, BureauLeiding outlined how the first operational plastic waste collection scheme in the Netherlands is recycling PVC pipe waste for reuse in three-layer sewage pipes. Capable of being recycled up to seven times with no loss of performance, waste PVC material can be recycled and used in new pipes.
He said: “Dutch legal opinion on the end-of-waste status of rigid PVC recyclate has created clarity for converters and this approach might have added value elsewhere. The investment and effort undertaken by VinylPlus in the sustainable development of the European PVC industry is paying off. The fact that drinking water companies, municipalities and large constructors are using PVC for certain applications as their material of choice demonstrate that the sustainability now is a credible story.”
Innovation and sustainability
In a last session showcasing PVC pipes innovations, Gianpaolo Contarini from IPM introduced for the first time a game-changing sealing technology allowing to dramatically reduce the intrusion of plant roots in PVC sewer pipes. This worldwide patented technology facilitates the use of PVC pipes in highly cultivated and vegetated areas.
Introducing the VinylPlus® Product Label, a new sustainability certification for PVC products in building and construction, Stefan Eingärtner of VinylPlus said the label enables organisations to ‘stamp their sustainability performance as a company, but also in their products’; this sends an important message to brand owners and local authorities on their overall environmental performance.
“The VinylPlus® Product Label is a key tool for PVC pipe manufacturers to demonstrate the sustainable progress we’ve made and for them to communicate that they are offering a more sustainable solution in PVC to their customers and markets,” he added.